there is a lot of information mixed in with misinformation on the net about which is the better service- cable or dsl high speed internet. when i worked as a high speed data technician for a local cable company, i ran into a lot of "experts" that had their say in the matter- and each one had a different story.
my thoughts are as follows:
"the fact of the matter is that there are too many variables that determine how reliable and fast your service will be to simply say dsl is better than cable, or the other way around."
CNET has what seems to be the most accurate review of both services. (
read all about it here)
the thing i hate to hear more than anything is "cable is faster than dsl" or "dsl is faster than cable". that is such a vague statement, and the people who make it probably don't even know what speed they signed up for. when i would show up to have a look at someones service, sometimes i would ask what speed they signed up for. 9 times out of 10 the answer was "the $19 one", or "the $34" one.
if you sign up for 1Mbps down 256Kbps up, it does not matter whether you have cable or dsl- your speed should be close to what you signed up for under normal circumstances. if you signed up for a 1Mbps service and your speed tests are only showing 300Kbps, that does not mean that dsl is faster than cable- it means that for whatever reason, bad modem, bad cable run or something wrong between you and the cable companies head-end, you cannot get the performance you signed up for. the same goes with the dsl providers.
i have had cable and i have had dsl. both services have always given me the speed i signed up for. i currently have cable- dsl is not available in my area. my last cable company had an
internet only service, which i thought was great because i like satellite tv better than cable tv (i got free cable internet and cable tv because i worked for the cable company- i still had dish network though).
where i am now i would prefer to have dsl because the cable company here does not offer an internet only service- you have to have cable tv too. but since dsl is not available here, i had to go with the cable company and forget about satellite tv (gotta have my broadband).
on the other hand, if i signed up for dsl here i would have to get their phone service too, and i use vonage and have no use for their phone service. so either way, i am not really getting what i want. if the cable company had an internet only service, i would have that and dish network. if dsl was available in my area and had an internet only setup, i would go with that. if they both were available and both offered and internet only service, i would go with the one that was the cheapest!
take it or leave it